Choosing a surrogacy agency is about much more than comparing success rates or costs. You’re choosing the people who will guide you through one of the most important experiences of your life.
A Christian surrogacy agency provides the same medical and legal framework as any reputable agency while approaching the journey through the lens of faith, compassion, and strong relationships.
This guide explains what makes a Christian surrogacy agency different, what questions you should ask before choosing one, and how to determine whether it’s the right fit for your family.
What Is a Christian Surrogacy Agency?
A Christian surrogacy agency is a surrogacy agency that combines professional medical and legal coordination with Christian values such as compassion, integrity, honesty, and respect for life and family.
Like other reputable agencies, it manages every stage of the surrogacy process, including surrogate screening, the surrogate matching process, legal contracts, fertility clinic coordination, pregnancy support, and postpartum guidance. The medical standards remain the same. What often differs is the philosophy behind the journey and the relationships built throughout it.
For many intended parents, that difference matters. Surrogacy is not simply a series of appointments and legal documents. It is a deeply personal experience that often follows years of infertility, pregnancy loss, or failed fertility treatments. Working with an agency whose values reflect their own can provide reassurance during an emotional time.
Likewise, many women interested in becoming surrogates are looking for more than compensation. They want to understand how they can help another family while working with an agency that values honesty, communication, and mutual respect.
Why Do Families Choose a Christian Surrogacy Agency?
Families choose a Christian surrogacy agency because they are looking for more than medical coordination. They want experienced professionals who will support them emotionally, communicate openly, and approach every stage of the journey with compassion and integrity.
For some families, shared faith is an important part of that decision. Others simply appreciate an agency whose values influence the way it communicates, resolves challenges, and builds relationships between intended parents and surrogates.
Many intended parents say they are looking for:
- transparent communication throughout the journey
- thoughtful surrogate matching
- comprehensive psychological screening
- strong relationships instead of transactional interactions
- emotional support before, during, and after pregnancy
- professionals who genuinely understand the surrogacy experience
As Amy, Founder of Surrogacy by Faith, explains:
“Besides meeting the basic requirements to become a surrogate, we look for the foundation of why she has a desire to become a surrogate. Is it simply for a second income, or is it something the Lord has placed on her heart? We look for genuine peace and confidence before moving forward.”
Rather than focusing only on qualifications, this approach also considers motivation, emotional readiness, and the desire to serve another family. Those qualities often contribute to healthier relationships and a more positive experience for everyone involved.
How Is a Christian Surrogacy Agency Different From a Traditional Agency?
A Christian surrogacy agency provides the same core services as any reputable agency, including medical coordination, legal guidance, and case management. The difference is usually found in how the journey is experienced rather than in the medical process itself.
Many faith-based agencies place greater emphasis on long-term relationships, shared values, emotional support, and open communication. They encourage intended parents and surrogates to build trust from the beginning instead of viewing the journey as a series of transactions.
That philosophy can influence many aspects of the experience, from the way surrogate matching is approached to how communication is encouraged throughout pregnancy and how support continues after delivery.
Because every agency is different, it is important to ask how those values translate into everyday decisions rather than assuming all Christian agencies operate in the same way.
How Can Shared Values Strengthen the Surrogacy Journey?
Shared values create a stronger foundation for trust throughout the surrogacy journey. While successful matches can happen between people with different backgrounds and beliefs, many intended parents and surrogates find that similar expectations make communication easier and help build stronger relationships.
Compatibility goes beyond medical qualifications. A thoughtful surrogate matching process also considers personalities, communication styles, expectations, and long-term goals. When both parties share similar priorities, conversations about pregnancy, delivery, and future contact often feel more natural.
Shared values also help when unexpected situations arise. Whether discussing hospital preferences, birth plans, or important medical decisions, beginning the journey with mutual understanding reduces uncertainty and allows everyone to focus on supporting one another.
Why Does Emotional Support Matter During Surrogacy?
Surrogacy is much more than a medical journey. It is an emotional experience that begins long before an embryo transfer and often continues long after the baby is born.
Many intended parents begin their journey after years of infertility, miscarriages, failed IVF cycles, or other difficult experiences. Surrogates also make a significant emotional commitment by carrying a pregnancy for another family. Throughout those months, questions, excitement, uncertainty, and unexpected situations are all normal.
That is why emotional support should never be treated as an optional service. A good agency does more than schedule appointments. It helps everyone feel informed, supported, and heard throughout the journey.
Strong communication also strengthens the relationship between intended parents and their surrogate. Regular check-ins, honest conversations, and clear expectations help prevent misunderstandings before they become larger concerns. Many intended parents later say that the relationship they built with their surrogate became one of the most meaningful parts of the entire experience.
When comparing agencies, ask what support is available beyond medical coordination. Some agencies continue providing guidance after delivery, helping intended parents transition into life with their newborn while also supporting surrogates during postpartum recovery.
How Do Christian Values Influence Important Decisions During Surrogacy?
Every surrogacy journey involves important decisions. Some are planned months in advance, while others arise unexpectedly during pregnancy. Understanding an agency’s values before beginning the journey helps everyone move forward with clear expectations.
These conversations may include topics such as embryo transfer, selective reduction, pregnancy termination, communication preferences, birth plans, and how unexpected medical situations are handled. Discussing these subjects early does not mean expecting complications. It means making sure intended parents and surrogates understand one another before legal agreements are signed.
A reputable agency encourages honest conversations rather than avoiding difficult topics. Transparency allows everyone to make informed decisions and reduces the risk of conflict later in the pregnancy.
Families should also understand how the agency works alongside fertility clinics, reproductive attorneys, and physicians throughout the surrogacy process. Knowing who guides each step helps intended parents feel more confident from the beginning.
What Should You Look for When Choosing a Christian Surrogacy Agency?
Choosing the right agency starts with asking the right questions. Beyond success rates and experience, you should understand how the agency supports intended parents and surrogates, how it approaches matching, and how its values influence the journey.
How Does Your Matching Process Work?
Ask how the agency approaches the surrogate matching process. Some agencies focus primarily on availability and medical qualifications, while others also consider personalities, communication styles, family expectations, and shared values.
A thoughtful match creates the foundation for a positive relationship throughout pregnancy and often contributes to a smoother overall experience.
What Psychological Screening Do Surrogates Complete?
Every reputable agency should clearly explain its psychological screening process before matching begins.
Psychological evaluations help assess emotional readiness, motivation, coping skills, previous pregnancy experiences, and the strength of a surrogate’s support system. This process helps protect intended parents and surrogates while preparing everyone for the emotional aspects of the journey.
What Are Your Surrogate Requirements?
Ask for a complete explanation of the agency’s surrogate requirements before beginning the application process.
Requirements generally include previous healthy pregnancies, medical history, lifestyle expectations, emotional readiness, and a reliable support system. Understanding these qualifications helps intended parents appreciate how carefully candidates are evaluated before entering the program.
How Will We Communicate Throughout the Journey?
Communication should never be left to chance.
Ask how often coordinators provide updates, how intended parents and surrogates typically communicate, and how the agency supports the relationship between intended parents and their surrogate from matching through delivery.
Clear communication builds trust and helps everyone feel supported throughout the pregnancy.
What Happens After the Baby Is Born?
Not every agency provides the same level of support after delivery.
Ask whether the agency continues supporting surrogates during postpartum recovery, whether intended parents receive guidance during the transition home, and whether both parties are encouraged to maintain contact if they mutually wish to do so.
How Are Unexpected Medical Situations Handled?
Although serious complications are uncommon, every agency should have a clear process for handling unexpected situations.
Ask who participates in important medical discussions, how intended parents remain informed, and how expectations are established before pregnancy begins. Understanding these procedures ahead of time provides reassurance and helps everyone approach the journey with confidence.
Asking these questions will give you a much clearer understanding of an agency’s philosophy than a brochure or website alone. They also make it easier to compare agencies based on the factors that truly matter to your family, not simply cost or location.
What Makes Surrogacy by Faith Different?
Faith-Centered Matching That Prioritizes Character and Compatibility
Choosing the right surrogate is about much more than medical qualifications. A successful journey also depends on shared expectations, open communication, emotional readiness, and mutual trust.
At Surrogacy by Faith, the surrogate matching process looks beyond eligibility. Every surrogate completes comprehensive psychological screening, and the team takes time to understand each woman’s motivation, personality, family support, and expectations before recommending a match.
As Amy, Founder of Surrogacy by Faith, explains:
“Besides meeting the basic requirements to become a surrogate, we look for the foundation of why she has a desire to become a surrogate. Is it simply for a second income, or is it something God has placed on her heart? We look for the undeniable confidence and peace to move forward that can only come from our Savior, Jesus Christ.”
This thoughtful approach helps create stronger relationships between intended parents and surrogates while giving both parties greater confidence from the very beginning.
Medical Standards, Safety, and Ethical Commitment
Surrogacy by Faith combines compassionate care with evidence-based medical standards to help provide the safest possible journey for everyone involved.
The agency follows American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) recommendations and works only with PGT-A tested embryos, helping reduce unnecessary risks for surrogates while improving the likelihood of a healthy pregnancy.
Before matching begins, intended parents and surrogates also discuss important medical expectations, including the agency’s policy regarding pregnancy termination. Surrogacy by Faith does not support pregnancy termination unless the mother’s life is at risk. Having these conversations before contracts are signed helps ensure everyone begins the journey with shared expectations and complete transparency.
| Many Surrogacy Agencies | Surrogacy by Faith |
| Medical and legal coordination | Medical and legal coordination with faith-centered support |
| Screening focuses primarily on eligibility | Medical and psychological screening also evaluates motivation, emotional readiness, and support systems |
| Communication styles vary | Relationship-focused communication throughout the journey |
| Postpartum support varies by agency | Ongoing support for both intended parents and surrogates after delivery |
| Embryo policies differ | Only PGT-A tested embryos are transferred following ASRM recommendations |
| Pregnancy policies vary | Expectations regarding difficult medical decisions are discussed before matching, including the agency’s policy regarding pregnancy termination |
| Team members may not have personal surrogacy experience | Most team members have personally experienced surrogacy, with a combined eight babies born through their own journeys |
| Compensation packages differ | Eligible surrogates may receive up to $13,000 in additional benefits beyond base compensation |
A Team That Understands Surrogacy From Personal Experience
Professional expertise is essential, but firsthand experience brings a level of understanding that cannot be learned from training alone.
Most members of the Surrogacy by Faith team have been surrogates themselves, with a combined eight babies born through their own journeys. Having personally experienced the medical process, the emotional ups and downs, and the unique relationship between intended parents and surrogates allows the team to provide guidance that is both practical and deeply empathetic.
As Amy explains:
“When you’ve personally experienced surrogacy, you understand the questions people are sometimes afraid to ask. That shared experience allows us to support intended parents and surrogates in a much more personal way.”
Rather than relying solely on professional knowledge, the team offers guidance rooted in lived experience. Whether answering questions about the surrogacy process, preparing for delivery, or helping families navigate unexpected emotions, they understand the journey because they have lived it themselves.
Personalized Support Before, During, and After Birth
Surrogacy is not a journey that ends once a match is made. It requires ongoing communication, guidance, and encouragement from beginning to end.
Surrogacy by Faith supports intended parents and surrogates throughout the entire journey, from the initial application and surrogate matching process to delivery and postpartum recovery. Coordinators remain available to answer questions, facilitate communication, and help everyone navigate important milestones with confidence.
Eligible surrogates may also receive up to $13,000 in additional benefits beyond base compensation through the agency’s Extra Care Package, reflecting Surrogacy by Faith’s commitment to caring for the women who help make parenthood possible.
Many intended parents say the agency’s relationship-first approach becomes one of the most meaningful parts of their experience. Rather than feeling like clients moving through a process, they feel supported by people who genuinely care about their family’s journey.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Christian Surrogacy Agency
Do You Have to Be Christian to Work With a Christian Surrogacy Agency?
Not necessarily. Every agency establishes its own requirements and mission. Some agencies work exclusively with Christian intended parents and surrogates, while others welcome people from different backgrounds who respect the agency’s values and approach.
If this question is important to you, ask about it during your first conversation. A reputable agency should clearly explain who it serves, how its values influence the journey, and what it expects from intended parents and surrogates before anyone moves forward.
Is a Christian Surrogacy Agency More Expensive?
Not automatically. The overall surrogacy cost depends on factors such as surrogate compensation, legal fees, insurance, fertility clinic expenses, and individual medical circumstances rather than whether an agency is faith-based.
Instead of comparing agencies based only on price, ask what services are included. Some agencies provide additional support throughout the journey, while others charge separately for services that may already be included elsewhere.
Can a Christian Surrogacy Agency Provide the Same Medical Care as Any Other Agency?
Yes. Christian surrogacy agencies work with fertility specialists, obstetricians, reproductive attorneys, psychologists, and other healthcare professionals just like any reputable agency.
Medical decisions follow established clinical guidelines. For example, Surrogacy by Faith follows American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) recommendations and transfers only PGT-A tested embryos to help protect surrogates and improve pregnancy outcomes.
How Important Is Psychological Screening?
Psychological screening is one of the most important parts of the surrogate screening process.
Medical qualifications alone cannot determine whether someone is prepared for surrogacy. A licensed mental health professional evaluates emotional readiness, motivation, coping skills, previous pregnancy experiences, expectations, and the strength of the surrogate’s support system.
That evaluation helps protect intended parents, surrogates, and ultimately the child by ensuring everyone begins the journey with realistic expectations.
Can Intended Parents and Their Surrogate Stay in Contact After Birth?
Yes, and many do.
Every relationship is unique. Some intended parents and surrogates stay in regular contact for years, while others exchange occasional updates or photos. The level of communication always depends on what feels comfortable for everyone involved.
Healthy relationships usually begin with honest conversations long before delivery. Establishing expectations early allows both sides to enjoy a relationship that feels natural rather than forced.
What Should Intended Parents Look for Above All Else?
Experience matters. Success rates matter. Medical expertise matters.
But above all, choose an agency you genuinely trust.
The people guiding your journey will help you navigate medical appointments, legal milestones, emotional highs and lows, and one of the most meaningful days of your life. Feeling supported, respected, and understood often becomes just as valuable as any statistic.
Is Surrogacy by Faith the Right Christian Surrogacy Agency for You?
Choosing a surrogacy agency is one of the most personal decisions you will make. The right agency should provide more than professional expertise. It should give you confidence that every step of the journey will be handled with compassion, transparency, and care.
If you’re looking for a Christian surrogacy agency that values relationships as much as results, Surrogacy by Faith offers a thoughtful approach built on faith, experience, and personalized support. From surrogate matching and psychological screening to legal coordination and postpartum guidance, the team remains committed to supporting both intended parents and surrogates throughout the entire journey.
Whether you’re hoping to grow your family or exploring how to become a surrogate, taking time to choose the right agency can make all the difference.
If you’re ready to begin your journey as intended parents, apply to become intended parents and speak with the Surrogacy by Faith team about your family’s goals.
If you’re interested in becoming a surrogate, start your surrogate application to learn whether you meet the qualifications and begin the screening process.
Sources
• American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM). Recommendations for Practices Using Gestational Carriers: A Committee Opinion (2022)
• American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM). Just the Facts: Gestational Carrier Care in the United States
• American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM). Consideration of the Gestational Carrier: An Ethics Committee Opinion (2023)
• Practice Committee of ASRM & SART. Recommendations for Practices Using Gestational Carriers: A Committee Opinion. PubMed.
• ASRM/ReproductiveFacts.org. Gestational Carrier Policy in the United States
• Golombok S, Murray C, Jadva V, MacCallum F, Lycett E. Families Created Through Surrogacy Arrangements: Parent-Child Relationships in the 1st Year of Life. Developmental Psychology, 2004.
• Jadva V, Murray C, Lycett E, MacCallum F, Golombok S. Surrogacy: The Experiences of Surrogate Mothers. Human Reproduction, 2003.
• Jadva V, Imrie S, Golombok S. Surrogate Mothers 10 Years On: A Longitudinal Study of Psychological Well-Being and Relationships with the Parents and Child. Human Reproduction, 2015.
• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART)
• American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG). Family Building Through Gestational Surrogacy